A mid-century house in Upper Three Arch Bay went on the market on Jan. 11 for $13.5 million. Built in 1958, it had one family as owners from 1962. The seller accepted an offer 13 days after listing, and the sale closed March 17 for $13.6 million, $100,000 over the asking price. According to the Orange County Register, the listing brokerage said the price set the all-time record for Upper Three Arch Bay.
That March, Laguna Beach's average single-family sale price rose 43.3% from March 2025, to $4,539,797. In the same month the median rose 14.5%, to $3,275,000. The town had 15 single-family closings that month, which together come to about $68 million. A $13.6 million sale would be about a fifth of that total. In a market this small, the monthly price figures mostly tell you which homes happened to close. The 2026 number that kept pointing the same way is how few homes are for sale.
A Month in Laguna Is a Dozen Houses
The monthly CRMLS market updates for the 92651 ZIP code, posted on the Laguna Board of REALTORS website, show that in 2026 the months with available reports had monthly closing counts as low as 3 and as high as 19. With so few sales, a single oceanfront home or a single canyon cottage changes the result.
| 2026 month | Single-family closings | Median price, change vs. same month 2025 | Average price, change vs. same month 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| January | 3 | $3,200,000, down 1.5% | $3,309,717, down 11.0% |
| March | 15 | $3,275,000, up 14.5% | $4,539,797, up 43.3% |
| April | 12 | $3,670,259, down 12.9% | $5,233,745, up 13.3% |
| May | 19 | $2,995,000, down 1.7% | $3,443,389, down 3.0% |
| September | 14 | $3,475,000, up 26.6% | $3,441,893, down 30.7% |
In April and September, the median and the average moved in opposite directions. In September 2026, the median rose more than a quarter from September 2025 while the average fell almost a third. These are records of different groups of houses, so the town's homes did not gain and lose value at the same time. The September 2026 report says so in its footnote: percent changes "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size."
The year-to-date figures smooth some of this out. From January through September 2026 there were 124 single-family closings, up 14.8% from the same period in 2025. The median over those nine months was $3,412,500, up 12.8%, and the average was $4,484,092. For a buyer, that $3.4 million median is the most reliable single price figure for 2026, and it still describes 124 different houses rather than one.
Inventory Dropped in Every Reported Month
Against the year before, supply came in lower every month. Each 2026 report shows fewer single-family homes for sale than a year earlier:
| 2026 month | Homes for sale, 2025 → 2026 | Months of supply, 2025 → 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| January | 92 → 72 | 9.4 → 5.8 |
| March | 113 → 93 | 11.5 → 7.6 |
| April | 124 → 92 | 12.8 → 7.1 |
| May | 133 → 93 | 13.1 → 7.4 |
| September | 108 → 77 | 9.6 → 5.7 |
Supply shrank from both directions. New listings fell 33.3% in January, 27.3% in March, 34.4% in April and 40.6% in May compared with the same months of 2025. Through September, year-to-date pending sales rose 15.2% and closings rose 14.8%, while new listings were down 6.1%. Fewer homes came to market, more sold, and the gap between the two reduced what was left.
In spring 2025, the town had more than 12 months of supply. By September 2026 it had less than six. That change will matter more to a buyer starting a search this winter than any single month's median. With 77 houses for sale across the whole ZIP code at the end of September, a buyer looking at one price range, one part of town and one style of house may find only a few real candidates at any given time.
Buyers Are Still Negotiating
Less supply has not taken away buyers' ability to negotiate. From January through September 2026, Laguna Beach single-family sellers received 96.3% of list price on average, up from 95.7% in the same period of 2025. At the year-to-date median of $3,412,500, a 3.7% gap comes to about $126,000. Individual months ranged from 94.5% in March to 99.0% in April.
Days on market show the same pattern. Year-to-date days active in MLS through September rose to 74, from 66 a year earlier, even though there were fewer homes to choose from. The Upper Three Arch Bay house had an accepted offer in 13 days. Across town, the year-to-date figure grew longer. Both fit the same market: buyers acted quickly when a house was priced to its condition and location, and took their time with the rest. In Laguna, pricing still decides how long a home sits, even with supply this low.
For a seller, condition and presentation set the price ceiling more than the citywide median does. For a buyer, the same figures show room to negotiate on a house that has been listed for a while, even with fewer options overall.
The Gated Beaches Are a Separate Market
The highest sales in Laguna Beach come from a few gated communities with their own beaches, and these sales are a different market from the town's median house. In June, the Los Angeles Times reported that an oceanfront home in Emerald Bay sold for $110 million, the highest home sale price in Orange County history. The previous record was a $70 million Laguna Beach sale in 2021. The Times reported that the house never officially went on the market. It also reported that the agent who handled both sides valued the steep lot alone at $40 million to $50 million, plus building costs of about $5,000 per square foot across roughly 10,000 square feet.
The same article says Emerald Bay is gate-guarded and accessible only to residents, with a half-mile beach set between two points that cut it off from neighboring beaches. The Emerald Bay Community Association describes the community as about 550 homes on 150 acres in unincorporated North Laguna. Water and wastewater service come from the separate Emerald Bay Service District, which was formed in 1961 and serves 538 properties.
Three Arch Bay in South Laguna has its own range of prices. In December 2025, the Register reported that 33 Bay Drive, one of eight homes on the sand there, was listed at $29.95 million with private steps to the beach. In 2024, the Orange County Business Journal reported an $18.8 million sale on S. La Senda Drive. Then came the $13.6 million record in Upper Three Arch Bay in March.
When one of these homes closes during a month with a dozen other sales, the citywide average rises. When none close, the average falls. The September 2026 average fell 30.7% while the median rose. That pattern fits a month with fewer sales at the top. A buyer shopping around the $3 million to $4 million median should compare against sales in that range and leave the enclave sales out of the comparison.
A Short FAQ
Did Laguna Beach home prices rise in 2026? Across the first nine months of 2026, the single-family median was $3,412,500, up 12.8% from the same period in 2025, based on 124 closings. That nine-month figure is more reliable than any single month, but it combines very different houses. Sales in your own price range and part of town will tell you more.
Is the condo market following the same pattern? It is even smaller. In September 2026 there were three townhouse and condo closings, with a median of $1,085,000, and 8 units for sale compared with 18 a year earlier. From January through September there were 15 closings, with a median of $1,500,000. That median is down 43.4% from the same period of 2025, which says more about which units sold than about what any one unit is worth.
Which figures should a buyer watch in each monthly report? Watch inventory and months of supply against the same month a year earlier. In every 2026 report shown here, both came in below 2025, while the year-over-year changes in the median and the average swung up and down. Percent of list price received is worth tracking beside them because it shows how much room buyers had to negotiate.
The September report has 14 single-family closings for the whole town. In a market that small, what matters for one house is how it compares with the few recent sales in its own price range and part of town. If you own in Laguna Beach and want to see where your home fits, The Summer Perry Group will prepare a complimentary valuation based on the sales closest to yours, with notes on the finishes and updates buyers are paying for.